About 10 years ago my husband (let’s call him Jack for the purposes of anonymity), broached the topic of opening up our marriage. He and his best friend came up with this idea while framing a house together and were quite proud of themselves for this ingenious, no strings attached and everyone wins idea 😀 It was mostly a suggestion made in jest but it started the discussions. I knew enough about myself, even then, to know I was not a casual relationship person and I likely could never embark on a sexual journey with someone without falling in love. I wasn’t even sure I could do the sex part without the love part first. My husband and his friend figured they could do it all and remain detached. Stay tuned for how that idea panned out a few years later 😉 The idea was brought up here and there as a fun discussion topic among our group of friends but that’s where it stayed at the time. A theoretical discussion.
About a year later everything changed. Jack found out I’d crossed the line between friendship and more with with my best friend (a guy) at the time. It was more of an emotional affair than a physical one, although physical boundaries were crossed as well. There were many reasons this happened. None of them make it ok. But this situation didn’t happen in the vacuum of a happy fulfilling marriage either. Needless to say, this was devastating all around. I broke Jack’s heart. I ruined our closest friendships. We lost many people over this situation much like what would happen in a divorce because our families were so intertwined. Our kids lost people who were like family to them.
IT WAS BRUTAL!
I was a broken person for a long time. Crossing some very avoidable lines made me lose my best friend and that was the greatest irony and tragedy. I missed him in the worst way! Almost overnight, my person — my friend, my confident, my support, the person who knew me in ways no one else did — was gone. We didn’t want to, but we severed all ties to work on our marriages and focus on our families.
Jack graciously forgave me and we started putting the pieces back together. We dissected the situation endlessly. We changed our patterns, spent more time together and talked about — “what now?” Jack brought up opening up our marriage again within a couple months. He figured it was a natural progression at the time and I said a tentative yes because I felt like I couldn’t say no after what I’d done to him. I personally wasn’t even close to ready for the kind of change that was about to lambaste me. But I was consumed by guilt and pushed through and tried to ignore those voices in my head. For any of you who have been down the affair path, do not do what we did! Don’t make a decision this big out of guilt! Trust me! Healing needs to happen on both sides so that you can be in a solid place together, or it will come back to haunt you. At the time I felt like this was the only way to hang on to my marriage. I didn’t know what other options I had. Don’t get me wrong — my husband didn’t “force” me into anything. I was curious about this path as well. The timing was just bad and it was my own guilt that kept me from standing up for what I needed.
Very quickly I discovered our ideas of “ok let’s explore this non-monogamy path” meant very different things. I assumed explore meant to learn, think, discuss and repeat — for months or longer, without actual action. Within weeks Jack had his first make-out session during a trip he was on. I found out after the fact, and was utterly devastated. I wasn’t ready at all. But he pushed on and a month later he slept with someone (again without me knowing until after the fact) while we were on a family vacation. I was completely thrown and spiraled into a depression over these actions I wasn’t ready for. I was trying to read things and learn about the concept and what others before us had gleaned from their experiences. We tried to talk, and I mean endlessly, but I felt constantly behind whatever was going on and I could not function that way. Even though Jack wasn’t hiding anything deliberately, it felt like he kept having affairs I’d find out about after. And every action he took, no matter how minor, chipped away at my psyche.
Jack is an adventurer and will try anything at least once. I am the complete opposite. I’m a thinker. I do things slowly. I weigh consequences and I scare easily. This path was not working for me even a little bit. Jack heard me and knew I was being wrecked by all this and tried to slow down. But, he didn’t understand my pace and what I needed. The way we are wired is fundamentally different, and to this day, the hurt we cause each other is because of this and never, I believe, a deliberate action on either side.
We ran into new issues when he started falling for and pursuing a friend of his, because I knew that this would not be a simple fling. She was a person who might be in my life in a major way. Even though the idea of polyamory made more sense to me, I knew this was potentially huge and harder, long term, than simply opening up to short term flings. He tried to go slowly on this one but I still kept getting surprised and freaked out. Honestly, at this point I felt like I was drowning. There was no way to make progress on this concept and figure out how it could roll out in such a way that could work for us both, because all I was doing was surviving. No matter what I tried, I could not get ahead of my overwhelm. I wrote a lot of poetry at the time and it was all very dark — drowning, falling off cliffs, slipping off the edge….you get the point. I was a wreck. And I was doing all this without a social network or support system to keep me grounded and stabilized. I felt desperately alone and scared. Thankfully things did not stay in this dark place, but trust me — this is NOT the way to embark on the non-monagamy journey. But I’ll save more for another day 🙂
Please stay tuned — I promise the story gets a bit more optimistic from here 🙂